Saturday, June 24, 2006

Little kids, big business.

June 25, 2006
A New Competitive Sport: Grooming the Child Athlete


THE parents of Beau Fraser have spent $30,000 to help him become a better athlete.

From the time Beau was 10, his parents, Gayle and Brian Fraser of Aptos, Calif., have paid for professional coaches, private trainers, athletic testing, baseball camps, tournaments and travel with elite teams — not to mention travel costs for the entire family to watch him play.

The extra help may or may not transform Beau into a professional baseball player, but, at 16, he is a starting catcher on his high school team. "Every little bit helps," he said.

As the nation's love of sports grows, more children are focusing on one sport at an early age — sometimes as young as 4 — and practicing it year-round. To keep up, parents spend thousands of dollars for team memberships, personal training and even private sports schools in the hope of turning their children into high-caliber athletes or landing college scholarships for them.

Often, though, the investments may do nothing more than help children make the team. "We're a sign of the times," Ms. Fraser said. "If they're not on a traveling team, then chances are your son or daughter isn't going to make the high school team in many areas."

Gary Mayes, like some parents, is not entirely comfortable with all this competitiveness, but he has still opened his wallet to help ensure that his son, Kyle, 17, gets a chance to play the sports he loves.

"It's generally out of hand," said Mr. Mayes, a high school baseball coach in Huntsville, Ala. "Parents that have the money are going to afford their kids every opportunity, and often there is no limit."

Some parents pay $200 to $400 for new baseball bats, he said, and pay $60 an hour for private trainers to make their children more athletically fit. The players who do not get extra help tend to fall behind, he said.

Mr. Mayes has paid $2,000 to $4,000 a year for eight years so his son could play on a traveling ice hockey team. The costs are for equipment, tournaments and gasoline, as well as hotel accommodations and airfare for the family. Mr. Mayes has often turned the sports travel into family vacations.

"It's not just investing in your kids' opportunity," he said. "You're also spending time with your kids. You can't measure that."

Sports camps, private sports schools and other businesses are springing up to meet the demand, which has blossomed in the last five years.

Velocity Sports Performance, based in Alpharetta, Ga., operates 65 sports training facilities nationwide that work with accomplished athletes in many fields, like Jeremy Bloom, the skier, and Charlie Villanueva of the Toronto Raptors basketball team. But increasingly, the centers are also catering to children.

As many as 130,000 youngsters come to Velocity centers each year, paying $15 to $45 for a one-hour to 90-minute session, two to three times a week. They receive general coaching on strength, speed and agility. Velocity's sales are growing by 30 percent a year, and 35 more franchised centers will open this year, said David B. Walmsley, a co-founder and chief executive.

And Sparq Training, in Portland, Ore., has built a business selling computerized athletic testing equipment and other products, like cones and medicine balls, to coaches, training centers and sports camps. Many students know the company for its Sparq Rating test, which analyzes their abilities in specific sports and gives them goals.

The company is scheduled to test 245,000 students this year at clinics, camps and schools. The tests are often free, but the company expects to sell more than $10 million worth of the equipment needed to conduct the tests to training centers, coaches and sports camps, said Andy Bark, a founder of Sparq.

The spending on young athletes has also trickled down to individual trainers like Andy McCloy, who calls himself a performance enhancement specialist. He works with about 60 student athletes a week in Huntsville, charging $30 to $150 an hour for sessions to improve their strength and speed. He also holds six-week sports camps that cost students $250 to $450 each.

The latest training tactics, Mr. McCloy said, can help less athletic children compete better. "Demand is increasing more and more, and it's not something I see letting up," he said. "Parents are competitive, and they don't want their kids to be left out."

Parents of serious athletes may take another route, spending up to $40,000 a year to send them to private sports-oriented schools with professional coaches and world-class trainers.

At IMG Academies in Bradenton, Fla., more than 700 students ages 10 to 18 train throughout the traditional school year in tennis, golf, soccer, baseball and basketball. The Pendleton Academy, on the IMGA campus, handles the students' academic schooling. More than half of the students live on a 300-acre campus and may train in their sport several hours a day, depending on the program. More than 85 percent of graduates receive college scholarships, the school says. Some 12,000 additional students attend programs on a weekly basis each year.

To help his son, Alex, win a scholarship, Stephen Pettee of Newhall, Calif., enrolled him in a public high school, William S. Hart in Santa Clarita, Calif., known for producing football stars like Kyle Boller of the Baltimore Ravens. Mr. Pettee also hired National Scouting Report, a company in Alabaster, Ala., that promises to market Alex's football talents to colleges.

National Scouting Report created a highlight video of Alex's performance on the field and a personal Web site with his photos, biography and news clippings. A representative regularly contacts colleges about Alex. The cost for it all is $2,300.

Letters from colleges expressing interest "have definitely picked up since we did this," said Mr. Pettee, who has invested in baseball, basketball and football training, camps and personal coaching over the years. "He doesn't need a scholarship, but it's fun," Mr. Pettee added. "College is definitely an expensive proposition."

As tuition costs rise, more parents than ever are seeking college scholarships for their children, according to National Scouting Report, which will help 4,000 students this year in that quest.

Yet it is relatively rare for students to receive substantial athletic scholarships, said Dave Galehouse, a co-author of "The Making of a Student Athlete," a guide to selecting a college, being recruited and playing college sports. At many colleges, he said, only a few exceptional players in sports other than the big attractions of football and basketball get full scholarships. Much more common are partial scholarships of as little as $1,000.

"You have parents who are spending thousands and thousands of dollars," he said. "I think a lot of people overestimate how much money they're going to get."

The financial outlays and the focus on youth sports elicit criticism from some experts on children's athletics and child psychiatry, who worry that it may be another sign that American parents have become overzealous about sports and put too much pressure on children. The results, they say, can include overscheduling, discouragement and injuries.

"Parenting has become the most competitive sport in America," said Alvin Rosenfeld, a child psychiatrist and a co-author of "The Over-Scheduled Child: Avoiding the Hyper-Parenting Trap" (St. Martin's, 2001). "It robs children of their childhood."

STEVE SPINNER created Sports Potential, a company in Menlo Park, Calif., that aims to keep such concerns in mind — for example, by guiding parents to enroll their children only in sports for which they are ready. He started the company with the help of Bill Bradley, the basketball star turned politician.

Sports Potential sells a $135 test called Smart, which analyzes the cognitive and physical skills of children ages 8 to 12 to determine potential in 38 sports. As part of the results, children and parents each get a personal Web site, where they can learn sports terms and drills and track their progress.

The company will start testing thousands of students this summer through local parks and recreation departments, and at sports camps in Dallas, Boston and San Francisco, Mr. Spinner said. Next year, the company plans to expand to 10 more cities.

"Research proves that not every child is right for every sport at the same age," he said. "Participating in the wrong sport regardless of the athleticism can lead to frustration, burnout and loss of enthusiasm for all sports. We're about helping parents be better parents."

Copyright 2006 The New York Times Company


Youth Soccer Has Grown Intricately Adult. Just Ask the I.R.S. Auditor.

FAIRFIELD, Conn., June 22 — Soccer seemed a simpler game when Jay Skelton coached his eldest son's kindergarten team nine years ago. This was before 5-year-olds went to goalie clinics, before teams took two-week trips to Europe, before the world's most popular game consumed his suburban life.

Today Mr. Skelton is president of his son's league, the Fairfield United Soccer Association, and he presides over a far more complex enterprise. Its 45 elite teams travel across the state and beyond for tournaments, training rigorously with paid college-level coaches. And its budget has boomed, with the group raising $392,000 in dues in 2004, according to tax returns.

The Internal Revenue Service has taken notice.

For the past two years, the association has been grappling with an I.R.S. audit that found the association failed to withhold taxes for a dozen paid coaches and scores of referees in 2003 and 2004. The I.R.S. assessed the association $334,441 in back taxes and fines, an amount Mr. Skelton says will drive the nonprofit league out of business.

The audit, which became public this month and is now under appeal, was not just a rude awakening for the association. It has raised this deeper, almost theological question relevant to many youth sports clubs across the country: Are they growing too fast for their parent managers to keep up?

"We didn't do anything wrong; we're volunteering to help our kids," said Mr. Skelton, a 46-year-old lawyer from Fairfield. "I'm not Joan of Arc, I'm not Rosa Parks; I'm just trying to get through this without losing my mind."

The Fairfield case — which centers on a dispute over whether coaches and referees are employees or, as the league contends, independent contractors — is not the first time the I.R.S. has fined a nonprofit youth sports league. But the penalty is one of the largest, and it has sent worried sports officials from Connecticut and other states scrambling to review the finer points of the tax code.

"A lot of clubs are going through the same type of audit situations, and they're watching our case to see how it turns out," Mr. Skelton said.

Indeed, youth sports clubs, literally once mom-and-pop operations, have grown so large and sophisticated that they now require payrolls, registrars and 1099 forms. Some boards have hired accountants and lawyers. United States Youth Soccer, a nonprofit national umbrella group, even offered a seminar on the use of independent contractors at its national convention in Houston in February, run by an I.R.S. representative.

Soccer may have run afoul of the I.R.S. partly because of its immense growth, from a pickup sport 30 years ago to a national phenomenon today, as judged by the avid interest in the World Cup this month.

In 1974, United States Youth Soccer counted 100,000 players; today it says there are more than 3 million. Fairfield United, which had 350 players a decade ago, today has 800. And while many of its coaches were parent volunteers back then, today it pays $2,500 a season to 25 skills coaches.

Soccer has also become big business. The Sporting Goods Manufacturers Association estimates there is a $215 million industry for wholesale soccer goods.

The IRS has declined to comment on the Fairfield case. But the agency "has an important interest in proper classification of workers," said Bruce I. Friedland, a spokesman. He said some groups intentionally mischaracterized employees "to avoid paying employment taxes."

Generally speaking, if an organization has direct control over a person's work, he or she is considered an employee. Independent contractors, on the other hand, tend to own their own businesses, work for a variety of clients, supply their own uniforms and gear, and have the right of refusal to work any particular assignment.

Mr. Skelton said that many of the league's skills coaches were employed by a Long Island soccer camp and defined under the contract as independent contractors. And many of the referees in the Fairfield case are older children officiating at the games of younger ones, for $20 to $40 a game.

"Are these 10-year-old children employees of Fairfield soccer? That's what we're facing," he said. All the workers in question received the payments they were due, he added.

Tax officials have also taken a hard look at high school sports. Mike Colbrese, the executive director of the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association, the governing body for that state's high school sports, said that 10 years ago, an IRS auditor concluded that the association's referees were employees, and that it had failed to withhold taxes for them. It took the association months to get that conclusion reversed.

In California, a 1995 law declared that officials were independent contractors after the state Employment Development Department created an uproar by assessing one high school sports governing body $200,000 for back employment taxes.

Fairfield United learned of the proposed penalties in the fall of 2004, and soon requested that the case be reviewed by the auditor's supervisor. The audit became public this month after an unidentified parent sent it to The Fairfield Minuteman, a newspaper that first published details about the case. The club hopes to learn the results of the supervisor's review by the end of the year.

Mr. Skelton, who played soccer in college, first got involved with suburban soccer by coaching his eldest son, Jaime, on a recreational team. Last November, he agreed to become president of the association, saying he wanted to guide it out of its I.R.S. problems so that the youngest of his sons, Mattie, 7, could play. The volunteer job has taken a toll, he said, keeping him up some nights until 3 a.m.

And he still coaches Jaime's team. On Thursday, as the team finished its last game of the season against Westport, losing 3-2, Mr. Skelton congratulated the sweat-soaked boys.

"You did everything we asked for this year, and you're twice the team you were at the beginning of the year," he said. Then he urged them to start thinking about the fall, when they would be raising money and practicing for a trip to Barcelona, Spain.

But some parents worry that travel soccer has become too much like big business.

Howard Rubenstein, 69, the referee administrator for the Eastern New York Youth Soccer Association, based in Rockville Centre, on Long Island, volunteers about 40 hours a week doing paperwork for the youth organization and a senior soccer group. He has an accountant check his books monthly.

A former chemistry teacher who started volunteering with soccer teams 35 years ago when he took pity on a coach "surrounded by 18 screaming first graders," Mr. Rubenstein said the corporatization of soccer had taken away "the fun of it."

"I remember when the parents used to run hat sales and bake sales and you had people who were the orange juice mother," he said. "You'd pile the kids in three or four cars and take them to a game. Now the clubs come up in brand-new 18-passenger vans."

Dante Gallucci, a Little League baseball leader in Fairfield, raised another worry. More aggressive I.R.S. scrutiny, he said, might make parents afraid to sit on boards of youth sports associations, especially if members are held liable for tax penalties, as could happen with Fairfield United.

"They have to remember, this isn't the board of directors of Enron," said Mr. Gallucci, a lawyer whose daughter plays with a Fairfield United team. "This is Joey who runs the pizza place who's really good at concessions, and a carpenter who's good at getting the kids to hit in T-ball, and a guy who's great on designing uniforms."

"We want to teach kids baseball and teach them something about growing up," he said. "We don't want to be involved in 27 hours of federal inquiry."

Copyright 2006 The New York Times Company


Post a Comment

<< Home